Money

KeyBanc Adjusts Cogent Communications' Valuation After Q4 Performance Misses Expectations

Author : JL Collins
Published Time : 2026-02-25

KeyBanc has reevaluated its stance on Cogent Communications Holdings, Inc. (CCOI), reducing its price target following a disappointing fourth quarter and the cancellation of a significant asset sale. Despite these setbacks, the company's management remains focused on enhancing profitability through strategic shifts towards higher-margin services and actively managing its balance sheet. This development underscores the challenges and strategic pivots telecommunications companies face in optimizing their financial performance and market position.

On February 23, financial analyst Brandon Nispel from KeyBanc adjusted his price recommendation for Cogent Communications, moving it from $30 down to $25. Despite this reduction, he maintained an 'Overweight' rating on the shares, signaling a belief in the company's underlying value, albeit at a lower expected peak. Nispel cited two primary reasons for the revision: Cogent's fourth-quarter results for 2025 were weaker than anticipated, and a previously announced letter of intent for the sale of data center assets did not materialize into a finalized transaction. This failure to close the deal contributed significantly to the stock's negative market reaction.

During the Q4 2025 earnings call, Cogent's CEO, David Schaeffer, provided insights into the company's financial strategies and operational performance. He emphasized that improvements in profit margins were largely due to aggressive cost-reduction initiatives and an increased emphasis on providing on-net products, which typically offer higher margins. These premium services now constitute a more substantial portion of Cogent's overall business. Specifically, on-net revenue escalated to 61% of total revenue in the last quarter, a notable increase from 47% in Q3 2023. Conversely, off-net revenue saw a decline to 39%, while noncore revenue dropped to less than 1% of total revenue, illustrating a deliberate corporate strategy to pivot towards more lucrative offerings.

Schaeffer also highlighted the robust expansion of Cogent's wavelength business, noting that the network had grown to cover 1,096 locations. The quarterly revenue generated from wavelength services reached $12.1 million, marking a substantial 74% increase from the previous year. For the entire fiscal year, wavelength revenue surged to $38.5 million, effectively doubling its 2024 performance. Additionally, the CEO addressed efforts aimed at fortifying the company's financial foundation. He reported an improved leverage profile and outlined plans to refinance $750 million in unsecured notes with secured debt once the make-whole period concludes in June 2026. This move is expected to optimize Cogent's debt structure and reduce financing costs.

Furthermore, the CEO confirmed that Cogent continues its pursuit of divesting 24 surplus data centers as a key component of its asset optimization strategy. Despite the previous letter of intent falling through due to unmet financing conditions, discussions with prospective buyers are still active. This ongoing effort is crucial for the company to streamline its operations, shed non-core assets, and generate capital that can be reinvested into strategic growth areas or used to further strengthen the balance sheet. The continuous focus on these asset sales demonstrates Cogent's commitment to maximizing efficiency and shareholder value amidst evolving market dynamics.

In summary, KeyBanc's revised outlook for Cogent Communications reflects recent financial underperformance and the unsuccessful data center sale. However, the company is actively pursuing internal operational efficiencies, particularly through a greater focus on high-margin on-net services and the expanding wavelength business. Management's strategic initiatives also include strengthening the balance sheet through debt refinancing and continued efforts to divest non-core assets, aiming to stabilize and improve its financial health despite the current market adjustments.