
Elevance Health (ELV) experienced a downturn in its stock performance during 2025, reflecting a demanding period for U.S. health insurers. While the company's revenue streams demonstrated a double-digit expansion, its earnings per share unfortunately contracted, signaling a challenging financial year.
A significant contributing factor to Elevance's financial struggles was the unexpected shift in its individual exchange business. What was once a profitable segment turned unprofitable, primarily due to a confluence of escalating medical cost trends and unanticipated alterations in risk pools. These factors collectively exerted considerable pressure on the company's margins within this crucial market.
In a decisive move to counteract the adverse trends, the health insurance industry, including Elevance, implemented substantial premium increases ranging from 20% to 30% across individual exchange policies. This strategic adjustment is anticipated to play a pivotal role in re-establishing positive margins for Elevance's individual exchange business by 2026, paving the way for financial recovery and stability.
Despite the recent challenges, Elevance's shares are currently trading at a single-digit multiple when compared to our projections of its normalized forward earnings power. This valuation is considered highly attractive, prompting a modest increase in our investment position during 2025. The current market pricing offers a compelling entry point for investors anticipating a strong rebound and sustained growth.