Island Travel

Avoiding the Overpriced Sweet Tooth Trap in Times Square, New York City

2025-10-11

New York City, a vibrant metropolis, presents an overwhelming array of activities and sights, making it challenging for visitors to choose how to spend their limited time. Navigating this vast urban landscape effectively requires discerning choices, especially when seeking authentic local experiences over common tourist pitfalls.

Among the many attractions, certain spots in Times Square are frequently cited as overpriced tourist traps. The M&M's store, in particular, is noted for its exorbitant prices and crowded atmosphere, offering little value despite its initial appeal to candy enthusiasts. For those with a penchant for sweets, the city provides a wealth of alternative, higher-quality, and more budget-friendly dessert destinations that promise a more satisfying culinary adventure.

Sidestepping the M&M's Times Square Experience

Times Square itself, while iconic and worth a brief visit for its sheer spectacle, often becomes an overwhelming and expensive hub for tourists. The M&M's store within this district exemplifies a common tourist trap, characterized by inflated prices and throngs of visitors. Despite its bright facade, the cost of branded merchandise and bulk candy can be disproportionately high, offering a less than ideal experience for families and individuals alike. Opting for alternative dessert spots across the city can lead to more enjoyable and economical indulgence.

For those eager to satisfy their sweet cravings, New York City offers an abundance of exceptional bakeries and confectionery shops that far surpass the M&M's store in both quality and value. Renowned establishments like Magnolia Bakery, famous for its banana pudding, or Levain, celebrated for its melt-in-your-mouth chocolate chip cookies, provide quintessential American dessert experiences. Additionally, the Little Cupcake Bakeshop, acclaimed for its cupcakes and Brooklyn Blackout Cake, presents gourmet options that are a testament to the city's rich culinary scene. These local gems offer authentic flavors and memorable treats, making them a much more worthwhile destination than the crowded and overpriced M&M's store.

Discovering Superior Dessert Alternatives in NYC

Beyond the well-trodden paths of Times Square, New York City is a treasure trove of culinary delights, particularly for dessert lovers. Moving away from the commercialized offerings of tourist traps reveals a vibrant landscape of bakeries and sweet shops that deliver on taste, quality, and atmosphere. Exploring these local favorites not only offers a better value but also provides a more genuine taste of New York's diverse gastronomic culture.

The city's dessert scene is rich with establishments that have earned their reputation through exceptional offerings. Magnolia Bakery's iconic banana pudding is a must-try, delivering a comforting and unforgettable flavor profile. Similarly, Levain Bakery's generously sized chocolate chip cookies are a beloved staple, known for their gooey centers and crispy edges. For those seeking more elaborate creations, the Little Cupcake Bakeshop stands out with its award-winning cupcakes and decadent Brooklyn Blackout Cake. These venues represent just a fraction of the incredible options available, providing sweet experiences that are both more authentic and more satisfying than the typical tourist-oriented offerings in Times Square.

more stories
See more